No, Dumbledore couldn’t simply reduce off his cursed hand in Harry Potter

For a sure era, the demise of Dumbledore within the sixth Harry Potter e-book and film was essentially the most devastating of plot twists. All of the sudden, Harry Potter and the remainder of the Harry Potter forged had misplaced their mentor and information via the world of Horcruxes. With out Dumbledore, our heroes’ probabilities of defeating Voldemort appeared slim.

It turned out that Dumbledore had partially engineered his demise by the hands of among the finest Harry Potter characters, Severus Snape. In retrieving the Horcrux inside Marvolo Gaunt’s ring, he had inflicted a lethal curse upon himself. Snape was in a position to include the curse in his hand, however he may solely give Dumbledore a yr to reside.

This story thread has precipitated followers to pose a query each time they watch the Harry Potter motion pictures so as: couldn’t Dumbledore simply reduce off his hand? Effectively, no, and there are clear explanation why.

Followers have been fiercely debating the problem on Reddit, with a transparent cut up between those that assume the curse had already unfold and people who consider Snape had managed to include it utterly right into a hand, which may in fact be amputated.

For the true reply, we should flip in fact to the Potter books and, notably, the scene in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows wherein the true preparations for Dumbledore’s demise are revealed by way of Snape’s recollections.

Snape does clarify to Dumbledore that he has “trapped the curse in a single hand in the meanwhile”, with that hand clearly blackened and ineffective from the consequences of the darkish magic. However then, he provides: “There isn’t any halting such a spell without end. It’ll unfold, ultimately, it’s the type of curse that strengthens over time.”

That appears fairly definitive, so far as we’re involved. That is the type of spell that would develop stronger and unfold, no matter what Snape and Dumbledore tried to do about it. Snape had merely managed to include the signs, enabling Dumbledore to nonetheless reside his life for the subsequent yr fairly than slowly rotting away.

In fact, it’s additionally true that Dumbledore felt his demise to be obligatory within the destiny of the Elder Wand, which led to Voldemort’s downfall and Harry’s triumph. He didn’t need to stick round for much longer anyway. Even when he may’ve reversed the curse, he may need determined to not.

For extra detailed breakdowns from the world of Potter, discover out why Harry Potter’s scar isn’t really a lightning bolt and be taught concerning the Harry Potter monster too terrifying for the flicks. We’ve additionally explored essentially the most heart-breaking Harry Potter scene that didn’t make the flicks and defined why we’ll by no means forgive the Harry Potter finale’s largest change from the books.

Elsewhere, discover the perfect motion pictures within the sequence with our guides to Ron Weasley and Hagrid. You can too stay up for new motion pictures with all the pieces you should know concerning the Improbable Beasts 4 launch date and the Harry Potter and the Cursed Youngster launch date. Or, discover out concerning the Harry Potter TV sequence launch date.

The creator of the Harry Potter sequence, JK Rowling, has made a variety of transphobic remarks on social media lately. When you’d wish to be taught extra about transgender equality or lend your help, listed below are two charities we encourage you to go to: the Nationwide Heart for Transgender Equality within the US and Mermaids within the UK.